einstien12, I think defeating Malistare gives you savior of the spiral,not Wizard city protecter(same thing as savior of wizard city) My bro said he had defeated, and I quote him,"a guy in a big tower(cant miss the tower, its HUGE) in the cave at the end of Triton avenue."Don't know how truthful that is, but you could give it a try.You don't have to finish EVERY single quest to get Wizard City Protecter.Hope this Info helps!!!
---AutumnRain Dreamer,lvl 11 and my bro, AndrewIce River, lvl 16
To get Wizard City Protector, you need to beat Lord Nightshade, the final boss of Wizard City. To get Savior of Wizard City, you need to do all quests, including side quests, in Wizard City.