While I'm not exactly sure of how to answer your question, I will explain hatching hybrids to you. Two hybrids when hatched together, will not make a different hybrid. However, if this does occur, you have a fifty percent chance of getting either your pet or the other character's pet. Good luck on your hatching. ~Shannon Skybreaker
When i hatch a pet with another player is it possible to end up with the same pet that I already have.
It is indeed possible. Ive received my Midnight Sprites back a lot in recent hatches. (Not that I'm complaining. This is what I want.) It's a 50/50 chance that you'll end up with your pet or the other person's pet unless those two combined can make a hybrid pet. Then you have a chance at getting a hybrid or a normal pet.