Why don't you try using Customer Service? It sounds like a bug. I had the same exact thing happen to me when I tried to get the Oasis Beetle in Krokotopia. I sent in a support ticket, and they fixed the bug.
Rebecca Bright Level 90 Miranda Shadowflame Level 90 Sabrina Emeraldblossom Level 86 Victoria Roseblood Level 82 Diana Moonflower Level 77 Christina Goldenheart Level 73