I would love to have them jump and play in the water that you have at your house. Say if you got the summer pool or got a bath tub OR if you water has a natural body of water they will play in it.
I would also like to see a game like tag or catch the pet.. Like it would see what pets you had in your house or around your house and say, Catch a goat monk. Then you have a minute to find it and if you 'catch' it you win some gold or something.
I wish they registered other items and didn't run through each other and the character. (Like how the characters bump into tables and ferns - not running through them.)
I tried dancing and clapping - my pets just did the same stuff as ever, so I don't know what that was about. But it would be fun if the "Emotes" did send a different instruction to the pets in a zone and they did act differently.
I'd also love it if the fish in a fish tank responded to the character when we approach the tank. They just float there ... staring. I wish they swam and darted more like real fish or did funny dances like the pets - they are magical after-all. :D
I used to have a dog that would howl everytime the TV show The X-Files came on and the opening music started to play. He evidently wasn't a big fan of the show. Maybe pets could react to whatever music scroll is playing in your house or even dance to music on the playable musical instruments. I also think it would be funny if the various dog and cat pets would act like they would irl. Dogs chasing cats, cats arching their backs and swatting dogs etc.